Which Apples Make the Crunchiest Coleslaw?
Honeycrisp is my first pick for a sweet, juicy crunch. Granny Smith is the one to buy for a firm, tart bite. Either holds its own against shredded cabbage. Choose between them by tasting the dressing: a sharp cider vinaigrette welcomes the sweetness of Honeycrisp, while a creamy dressing with a little honey benefits from the tang of Granny Smith.

Four crisp apples and when to use them
| Apple | What it brings | Where it works best |
|---|---|---|
| Honeycrisp | Juicy snap, balanced sweetness | Cider vinegar and Dijon dressing |
| Granny Smith | Firm flesh and a sharp green-apple flavor | Creamy slaw for a pulled pork sandwich |
| Fuji | Dense crunch and pronounced sweetness | Lime dressing with jalapeño and cilantro |
| Pink Lady | Firm, sweet-tart matchsticks | Red cabbage with lemon and olive oil |
Cut for crunch
Freshness matters as much as the variety. Try a slice before making the whole bowl. It should snap when you bite it. Quarter and core the apple, leave the peel on, then set each quarter on a flat face. Slice into planks about ⅛ inch thick. Stack two or three planks and cut into matchsticks of the same width. Grating releases juice and leaves the fruit hard to pick out among the cabbage shreds.
Quick apple coleslaw for four
Whisk 3 tablespoons mayonnaise, 1 tablespoon cider vinegar, 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard and a pinch of salt in a large bowl. Taste with a piece of apple. If you’re using Granny Smith and want a sweeter dressing, stir in ½ teaspoon honey.
Cut one medium apple into matchsticks and toss them straight into the dressing to coat the cut faces. Add 3 cups finely shredded green cabbage and one coarsely grated carrot. Fold until lightly coated. Taste a forkful that includes both cabbage and apple before adjusting the salt. Serve as four side portions, or tuck a small handful into each sandwich.
For the crispest bowl at serving time
If you’re taking the slaw to dinner, shred and dry the cabbage ahead and refrigerate it separately from the dressing. Keep the apple whole until close to serving. Slice it, toss it with the dressing, then fold in the cabbage and carrot. For a picnic spread with a little heat, borrow the chile idea from our jalapeño coleslaw and pair it with sweet Fuji.
