Easy recipes, cooking tips & everyday inspirationGet the newsletter ↗
Cooking Club logoCooking ClubTHE EVERYDAY RECIPE CLUB
Blog › Kitchen guides

How to Make Pasta Salad That Stays Creamy

The easiest way to keep pasta salad creamy is to dress it twice. Toss the cooled, well-drained noodles with enough dressing to coat them, then refrigerate a few spoonfuls of dressing separately. Give the salad a second toss just before serving. Pasta takes up some of the dressing as it sits, so that last spoonful goes further at the table than it would the night before.

Creamy chicken penne pasta salad with olives and vegetables

Start with noodles that taste good cold

Short shapes are easy to coat. Try ditalini for a chopped salad or penne for bigger pieces of chicken and vegetables. Before draining, cool one noodle under the tap and taste it. It should be tender all the way through and still hold its shape. A firm, chalky center will feel even firmer in a chilled salad.

Drain before you dress

For a cold mayonnaise or yogurt dressing, rinse the cooked pasta briefly under cold water, then shake the colander well. Tilt a few pieces of penne to let water run out of the tubes. Drain olives and beans separately. If water is already collecting at the bottom of the mixing bowl, tip it out before adding the dressing.

Save the last quarter of the dressing

As a starting point, if your recipe makes 1 cup of dressing, toss the salad with ¾ cup and refrigerate the remaining ¼ cup in a covered container. Fold from the bottom of the bowl so the noodles, vegetables, and meat all get coated. Cover and chill the salad. Just before serving, stir it once, then fold in the reserved dressing a spoonful at a time. Stop when the noodles look glossy and the dressing clings to a forkful.

Fix the texture by looking at the bowl

  • Dry noodles, clean bottom: Fold in some reserved dressing. If you used it all, whisk a spoonful of the original creamy base with a little of the recipe’s liquid before adding it. Straight mayonnaise can sit in clumps on cold pasta.
  • Thick coating, heavy forkful: The salad already has enough dressing. Fold in a teaspoon of cold water at a time to loosen it. Taste before adding more vinegar or lemon juice.
  • Liquid pooling underneath: Toss once. If a puddle remains, lift the salad into a clean bowl with a slotted spoon. Taste a noodle before deciding how much dressing to add back.

Try the method with three different dressings

Our smoked turkey pasta salad coats ditalini and kidney beans in mayonnaise, balsamic vinegar, and Dijon. Whisk those ingredients together before reserving a portion so the second toss brings back the herbs and tang along with the creaminess.

For sweet-sour broccoli pasta salad, yogurt, apple juice, and cider vinegar make a lighter dressing. Give the broccoli a good shake along with the pasta: water caught in the florets can thin that dressing before it reaches the table.

In creamy chicken penne pasta salad, condensed chicken soup and lemon juice form the dressing. Set some aside after mixing the two. It’s easier to coat the chilled penne evenly with a spoonful of the blended dressing than with a squeeze of lemon alone.