How to Make a Holiday Dessert Tray with Bars and Brownies
For a holiday tray, choose three bites you’d actually want to eat one after another: a plain cocoa brownie, a tart lemon square, and a chewy caramel bar with pecans. The lemon breaks up the chocolate, and the pecans give the last bite a little crunch. For twelve guests after dinner, set out eight small pieces of each kind to start. That gives everyone two tastes, with the rest of the pans available for refills.

Choose three pans that share an oven temperature
All three recipes bake at 350°F. Start with the brownie caramel pecan bars in a 9-inch square pan. The brownie base takes 15 to 20 minutes. Make the caramel while it bakes, then add the topping, chocolate chips, and pecans. Leave the pan undisturbed on a rack so the soft chips keep their shape.
Next, slide the classic cocoa brownies into the oven in a 13-by-9-inch pan. Bake for about 25 minutes, checking for the top to spring back lightly. Skip the optional nuts in this batch for a soft, even crumb alongside the crunchy pecan bars.
Finish with the white chip lemon bars. Allow about 15 minutes for the shortbread crust and another 15 minutes after adding the chips and lemon filling. These need a 9-inch square pan too. If you own only one, wait until the caramel slab is completely cool, lift it out using its foil sling, then wash and dry the pan for the lemon bars.
Cut clean pieces in three shapes
Let each slab cool completely. Cut the cocoa brownies into small squares, the pecan bars into narrow fingers, and the lemon bars into squares halved diagonally. To make even triangles, cut a row of squares first, then slice each square corner to corner. Wipe the blade between cuts, especially when moving from sticky caramel to pale lemon filling. Use a thin spatula to lift each piece from underneath.
Arrange the tray so guests can reach every piece
Place the lemon triangles in a loose fan on one side. On the other side, line up the cocoa squares with a little room for the serving tongs. Tuck the caramel fingers into paper candy cups to keep sticky edges apart. A small separate plate marked “contains pecans” makes the nut topping easy to spot. Dust the lemon bars with powdered sugar before placing them so the dark brownies stay clean.
What to do ahead
Bake the day before and keep the varieties in separate covered containers once cool. Refrigerate the lemon bars. On the day, cut and arrange a first round shortly before serving. Set aside a few uncut rows for refills: the cut edges stay tidier, and you can adjust the sizes once you see which dessert guests reach for first.
