Easy recipes, cooking tips & everyday inspirationGet the newsletter ↗
Cooking Club logoCooking ClubTHE EVERYDAY RECIPE CLUB
Blog › Kitchen guides

How to Make a Crispy Panini Without a Panini Press

Set a sandwich in a warm skillet and a smaller skillet on top of it. The weight brings the bread into contact with the hot metal all the way to the corners. Flip once and you get a golden crust on both sides. A wide spatula works, too, if you only own one pan.

Grilled whole-wheat panini halves with tomato, basil, spinach, red onion and feta
Thin tomato slices and finely crumbled feta keep this tomato basil panini easy to press.

Build one sandwich that will flip cleanly

Start with two slices of sourdough about ½ inch thick or a small ciabatta roll split lengthwise. For a tomato and mozzarella panini, use about 2 ounces of thinly sliced low-moisture mozzarella, two thin slices of tomato, a few basil leaves and 1 teaspoon of olive oil. Blot the tomato on a towel. Layer half the cheese on each slice of bread, tuck the tomato and basil between them, then brush the two outside faces lightly with oil.

Toast, press and flip

  1. Warm the skillet. Heat a heavy skillet over medium-low heat for a couple of minutes. Set the sandwich in the dry pan. Listen for a gentle sizzle. An aggressive hiss or smoking oil means the pan needs to cool a little.
  2. Press the first side. Set a smaller skillet with a clean, flat underside directly on the bread. Its own weight is usually enough. With a spatula, press gently across the middle and corners a few times as the sandwich cooks. Start checking underneath after 2 minutes. The first side usually takes 3–4 minutes and should be evenly golden.
  3. Turn it once. Lift off the top skillet using a mitt. Slide a wide spatula under the sandwich and turn it over close to the pan. Replace the weight and cook for another 2–3 minutes, checking for a crisp second side and softened cheese.
  4. Let steam escape. Rest the panini on a wire rack for about a minute before cutting. On a flat plate, steam collects under the bottom slice just as the crust is at its crispest.

Adjust the heat before adding more weight

Dark bread, cold center? Lower the heat. On the next sandwich, slice the cheese thinner and spread it to the edges. Pale patches? Rotate the sandwich a quarter turn and press the pale corner with the spatula. Filling sliding out? Lift the weight and finish with a light hand on the spatula. Extra pressure can squeeze tomato juice straight into the crumb.

Try the tomato, basil and feta version

Our Tomato Basil Panini pairs spinach, tomato, basil and red onion with crumbled feta on whole-wheat bread. Dry the spinach, slice the onion thinly and scatter the feta in an even layer. Feta softens but keeps its shape, so judge this version by the golden bread and a warm center. Slice diagonally and serve while the edges still crackle.